Hello All
Well, Eventually I decided to buy the Yamaha KX8 as I really didn't want Fatar/Studiologic due to the erratic velocity sensing mentioned here. Little did I know that the FC3 pedal isn't supported; it doesn't explicitly say this on the Yamaha website and Dolphin Music didn't flag the error in my order, ho hum. I was quite annoyed when I plugged it in and nothing whatsoever happened.
Fortunately, I have a MIDI encoder board which has continuous control inputs on it and it was a very simple exercise to *cringe* cut off the jack plug of the FC3 and wire it into this board. I was pleasantly surprised to find that the FC3 has the full 0-127 MIDI output range, which I did not expect from the potentiometer.
The KX8 has a very nice feel although it has more mechanical "clatter" than the much more expensive Numa. This is a bit distracting when playing quietly through open-back headphones, but for £390 I can't really complain.
As far as the feel goes, I don't think the Numa justifies the expense. I've now played PTQ for about 8 hours through both the KX8 and my brother's Numa and I find it easier to play consistent dynamics in the ppp-mf range on the KX8 than on the Numa. The comment by another poster some time ago that the more you play it, the more it becomes "your" piano is very true; I'm getting to really like the Erard now and concentrating on the tiniest nuances in performance rather than "what's wrong with this sample-set?". Certainly pitting my new keyboard and PTQ against the badly-regulated bottom-of-the-range Yamaha upright we have at school, I know which I'd rather play, both mechanically and sonically.
Eagerly awaiting the forthcoming update,
Best//Neil